top of page

Why You Can't Trust Yourself from Inside an Affair

  • Writer: Lauren LaRusso
    Lauren LaRusso
  • Aug 3
  • 3 min read

Navigating the emotional chasm of an affair is a deeply intricate and distressing experience. It's not unusual for individuals caught in the throes of infidelity to express feelings of self-doubt, carrying sentiments such as "I can't trust myself anymore" or "I question my judgment entirely." Here, I unpack the perceptions and dynamics that contribute to this distrust and offer insights for those encountering such challenges.


The Obliteration of Clarity

From the moment an affair begins, it can feel as though your perception is radically altered. The intoxicating allure of new love, attention, and experiences can overshadow the mundane yet steady world of a long-term relationship. When a new person sees you in a different light, amidst years of familiarity, it is an exhilarating transformation. However, this excitement skews reality, creating a rift in how you see yourself and your current relationship.


Intermittent Contact and Its Addictive Nature

Intermittent contact with the person involved in the affair—its unpredictability and anticipation—mirrors the emotional turmoil experienced by addicts. Your nervous system reacts dramatically, and you might find yourself demonstrating behaviors akin to addiction. The constant longing for the next interaction takes over, making the entire affair a whirlwind that obscures your ability to trust your judgment.


The Shadow of Past Relationships

Comparison between your present relationship and the tumult aided by an affair often leads to skepticism. When individuals contemplate leaving a long-term partner for a new interest, the fear that they’re merely trading one set of issues for another is commonplace. While the faces may change, the underlying cycles of secure love and daily life continue to present themselves.


Recognizing Personal Patterns

Self-doubt often arises from unaddressed issues within ourselves and our previous relationships. An affair circumvents the challenging yet necessary introspection required to truly address these patterns and dynamics. Many times, individuals find themselves entrapped in similar cycles with new partners simply because the core issues haven't been resolved.


Discernment in Relationships

Following my own experience with divorce after discovering the affair, discernment became pivotal in my journey toward self-trust. Learning to check in with my feelings, patterns, and the dynamics in relationships honed my ability to make choices that aligned with my deepest values and desires. It’s essential to cultivate this practice of discernment, taking the time and space to understand ourselves in the context of relationships.


The Path Forward

The intricate process of understanding and healing from an affair demands a meticulous examination of one's role in relational dynamics. By embarking on this journey of self-discovery, you cultivate the ability to trust yourself and make decisions that are congruent with your true self. Therapy and self-work are invaluable tools in this process, allowing you to become the stable source of your own wellbeing.


For those struggling within an affair and grappling with self-trust issues, know that you're not alone. Through dedicated self-reflection and growth, you'll forge a path toward becoming someone who comprehends and trusts their place in any relationship.


For more in-depth guidance, consider exploring specialized resources like the Decision Making Method for Unfaithful Spouses for individuals in affairs to get clarity, the Survive to Thrive Masterclass for betrayed spouses, and the Finding Freedom Masterclass for affair partners.


You can learn more about this by watching my YouTube Video on the topic.


Remember that we offer resources and support to help you if you're struggling because of an affair. You're not alone. Go to www.laurenlarusso.com/start-here


Lauren LaRusso, LPC, LMHC | Founder & Coach
Lauren LaRusso, LPC, LMHC | Founder & Coach

 
 
 

Comments


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

©2026 Lauren LaRusso

bottom of page